Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. ScentClones.com is supported by readers. Some of the links below are Amazon affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at absolutely no extra cost to you. This keeps the dupe tests coming and the coffee flowing. Thank you for the support!❤️
Important Note: All opinions in this post are 100% my own, based on my personal testing and experience. None of these fragrances or brands are sponsoring this post or influencing my reviews in any way.
Nothing hits quite like that deep, glowing **amber frankincense** warmth in the colder months. It’s smoky, resinous, a touch churchy, and instantly makes you smell like you’ve got your life together – even if you’re just heading out for coffee. I’ve been obsessed with these kinds of scents for years: the kind that feel ancient, mysterious, and ridiculously expensive. But the real deals from niche houses? Easily $250+ a bottle. Hard pass when rent is due.
That’s why I dropped my own cash on a bunch of affordable **amber frankincense dupes** – all under $50 – and tested them properly: on skin, on clothes, in cold weather, around people who’ll tell you straight if you stink. Some were meh, a couple went way too sweet or synthetic, but six stood out as legit contenders that capture that smoky resinous magic without the insane price tag.
These aren’t pretending to be perfect clones – nothing at this price truly is – but a few get shockingly close to that luxe incense glow, and all of them feel way richer than they cost. Ideal for holiday evenings when you want compliments without the buyer’s remorse.
Layer them with these for even deeper luxury:
Let’s dive in and find your next winter signature.
Most Searched Clones Right Now!
Table of Contents
- Quick Comparison Table
- How I Tested These Amber Frankincense Dupes
- #1: Afnan Supremacy Incense – The Smokiest Amber Frankincense Dupe
- #2: Lattafa Khamrah – Resinous Warmth With a Sweet Edge
- #3: Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition – Glowing Sweet Amber Resin
- #4: Zimaya Ilham Al Oud – Smoky Oud-Frankincense Beast
- #5: Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense – Deep Incense Smoke
- #6: Rasasi La Yuqawam Pour Homme – Classic Resinous Amber Incense
- What If You Want Lighter Amber (Less Heavy Smoke)?
- Where to Buy These Right Now
- Final Thoughts + My Most-Reached-For Pick
- FAQ
- Related Posts
Quick Comparison Table
| Rank | Fragrance | Smells Closest To | Current Price | Longevity | Size | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Afnan Supremacy Incense | Amouage Interlude Man (smoky frankincense beast) | ≈ $35–$45 | 10+ hours | 100ml | Check Price |
| #2 | Lattafa Khamrah | Kilian Angels’ Share (boozy resinous amber warmth) | ≈ $35–$50 | 9–12 hours | 100ml | Check Price |
| #3 | Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition | Erba Pura or sweet resinous amber glow | ≈ $40–$50 | 8–10 hours | 60ml–100ml | Check Price |
| #4 | Zimaya Ilham Al Oud | Deep oud-frankincense resinous smoke | ≈ $25–$35 | 8+ hours | 100ml | Check Price |
| #5 | Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense | Spicy amber-incense depth (Creed-inspired twist) | ≈ $40–$50 | 10+ hours | 100ml–150ml | Check Price |
| #6 | Rasasi La Yuqawam Pour Homme | Tom Ford Tuscan Leather (resinous amber-leather) | ≈ $40–$50 | 9–11 hours | 75ml | Check Price |
How I Tested These Amber Frankincense Dupes
Look, I’m not the type to spray a fragrance once in my bedroom, sniff it for five minutes, and declare it a winner. Smoky resinous scents like these amber frankincense dupes are complex beasts — they change dramatically over hours, react differently to skin chemistry, and can smell heavenly in the opening but turn into a headache later. I’ve wasted money before on hyped-up bottles that fell apart after two hours, so this time I went full obsessive mode to make sure you get the real story.
I bought every single one of these with my own money — no PR samples, no discounts, nothing. All arrived straight from Amazon (the exact product links you’ll see below are what I ordered from). Testing happened over several weeks in actual cold weather (late November into December 2025), because that’s when heavy incense and resin notes truly come alive. Warm summer skin kills them; crisp winter air makes them glow.
Here’s the exact, transparent process I followed for every fragrance — no shortcuts:
- Skin + fabric testing: Two sprays on bare wrist (skin) and two on my wool jacket or hoodie sleeve (fabric). This matters a ton — some cling eternally to clothes but vanish on skin, others do the opposite. I needed to know real-world performance.
- Blind initial sniffs: My partner labeled the bottles with numbers and sprayed without telling me which was which for the first round. This caught any immediate “this smells cheap/synthetic” reactions without brand bias sneaking in.
- Full-day wear rotation: Each dupe got at least three full days of exclusive wear. I rotated through them systematically, taking notes at the 30-minute mark, 2-hour, 4-hour, 8-hour, and next-morning stages. If something impressed, it earned extra wear days.
- Projection & sillage tracking: I measured how far the scent carried — arm’s length, room-filling, or hallway-filling — and timed when it dropped to a skin scent. Real-life tests: grocery store runs, coffee shop hangs, family dinners, even a couple of outdoor holiday market visits in 35–45°F weather.
- Compliment & reaction log: I kept track of unsolicited feedback. Did strangers ask what I was wearing? Did anyone say it smelled smoky or churchy? Did my partner lean in or lean away? Brutal honesty here — some pulled compliments, one got a polite “it’s strong.”
- Cold-weather specific trials: These aren’t summer scents. I deliberately wore them when it was chilly, layered with sweaters and coats, to see how the resins bloomed in low temps and how wind affected projection.
- Direct side-by-side comparisons: I own small decants of pricier smoky resins (Amouage Interlude Man, Kilian Angels’ Share, a bit of Tom Ford Amber Absolute). I did wrist-vs-wrist battles: expensive original on left arm, affordable dupe on right. Timed how long they stayed similar and where they diverged.
- Over-spray tolerance test: On a couple of evenings, I went heavy (5–6 sprays) to see if they became cloying or maintained that luxe feel. Important for date nights or holiday parties.
What stood out the most during testing? The gap in longevity and depth isn’t as huge as you’d think. Two of these under-$50 bottles hung right with the niche stuff for the first 6–10 hours — the smoky frankincense and warm amber glow was there, rich and addictive. But some started strong then faded or turned sweeter than I wanted. One opened with pure church-incense magic that made me stop in my tracks.
I also paid close attention to mood and confidence factor. These aren’t light, crowd-pleasing freshies — they’re bold, introspective, winter-night scents. I wanted ones that made me feel put-together and mysterious without overwhelming a room or giving me a headache by hour four.
At the end of it all, this ranking reflects pure performance per dollar: how much smoky, resinous, insanely luxe amber frankincense character each one delivered, how long it lasted, and how wearable it felt in real life. No influencer hype, no “exact clone” fairy tales — just straight talk from someone who’s spent far too much on fragrance and finally learned to hunt the hidden gems.
Now let’s dive into the countdown — starting with the one that absolutely dominated for raw smoky intensity and left me stunned at the price.
#1: Afnan Supremacy Incense – The Smokiest Amber Frankincense Dupe That Punches Way Above Its Price
If you’re chasing that deep, churchy **amber frankincense dupe** vibe — the kind that fills a room with smoky resins and makes people turn their heads — Afnan Supremacy Incense is the one that blew me away the most. It’s widely talked about as an inspired take on Amouage Interlude Man (that $300+ smoky incense beast), and after wearing it side-by-side, I get why.
The opening hits hard with spicy oregano and herbs — it’s bold, almost medicinal at first, like walking into an old cathedral with burning incense swinging. Not sweet, not polite. Then the amber and opoponax kick in, wrapping everything in warm, glowing resins. The dry down? Pure smoky frankincense with hints of leather and oud lingering forever. It feels insanely luxe, especially in cold weather when the smoke really blooms.
My real-life testing: I wore this to a holiday dinner — 4 sprays total. Projection was massive for the first 3–4 hours (people across the table noticed), then settled into a rich skin scent that lasted until the next morning on my jacket. On skin alone, easily 10+ hours. In 40°F weather, it felt mysterious and confident without being overwhelming (as long as you don’t go crazy with sprays).
Is it identical to Interlude Man? No — the original has a touch more depth and smoothness. But for the price? This gets scary close in the heart and base, with even stronger initial smoke for some people. It’s not for everyone — if you hate heavy incense or anything “churchy,” skip it. But if that’s your jam, this is the best smoky **amber frankincense dupe** I found under $50.
“It’s a very smokey and earthy incense scent. Not sweet at all… Once it’s fully dried down you actually get a very nice smooth almost creamy incense smell.”
— Reddit user Fun-Power2949 on r/fragranceclones (July 8, 2024)
“All I can say if you like smoke and oud this is your thing… the smoke is definitely in your face at times.”
— Same thread, highlighting the bold smoky power
“The sillage is massive for the first 1-2 hours… the smokiness and incense is robust… borderline sickly when the vanilla shows up” (but great for bedtime wear).
— Reddit user Powerful-Ship-7509 on r/fragranceclones (October 20, 2024)
“Afnan Supremacy Incense is the sweetest on the opening [compared to other Interlude clones]… but they are all great.”
— Reddit comparison thread on r/fragranceclones (February 7, 2025)
Pros: Insane longevity, huge projection early on, captures that ultra-luxe smoky resin vibe perfectly for winter/holidays.
Cons: Opening can be sharp/herbal (not for blind buy if you hate oregano), very bold — not office-safe for most.
Current price: ≈ $35–$45 (100ml)
If you want the smokiest, most intense amber & frankincense experience on a budget, grab this one first. It’s the reason it took #1 — pure winter luxury in a bottle.
#2: Lattafa Khamrah – Resinous Warmth With a Sweet Edge (Perfect Holiday Coziness)
Okay, full disclosure — Lattafa Khamrah isn’t the smokiest amber frankincense dupe out there. It’s sweeter, boozier, and more gourmand than pure churchy resins. But hear me out: that underlying myrrh, benzoin, and amberwood give it a gorgeous resinous backbone that feels warm and luxurious, especially in winter. It’s the one I kept reaching for cozy holiday nights when I wanted compliments without the heavy smoke overload.
If you’ve read my deep dive on Angels’ Share dupes or the brutal side-by-side Khamrah vs Angels’ Share, you know this is the star of that world. It opens with a blast of cinnamon-dates (like fresh-baked apple pie with a boozy twist), praline creaminess in the middle, and dries down to vanilla-tonka warmth grounded by subtle myrrh and resinous amber. No frankincense listed, but the benzoin and myrrh add that balsamic, slightly smoky resin glow that ties beautifully into this roundup.
My testing experience: Wore this to a few holiday gatherings — 3-4 sprays. It projected strong for 4-5 hours (sweet cinnamon cloud that got “you smell amazing” comments), then settled into a rich, resinous skin scent that lasted 9-12 hours easy (eternal on clothes). In cold weather, the resins really shine through the sweetness, making it feel more expensive than it is. Side-by-side with pricier boozy gourmands, it holds up shockingly well in the drydown.
It’s not a straight smoky incense bomb like #1 — if you want zero sweetness, skip it. But for that cozy, resinous holiday vibe with crowd-pleasing warmth? This is the best affordable pick with real amber/myrrh depth.
“Khamrah, to me, is a warm, spicey, creamy/lactonic gourmand. The notes that stand out the most to me are cinnamon, dates (wow, gorgeous!), praline, Tuberose, and incense… hint of incense and woody notes in the background that grounds this sweet treat.”
— Reddit user (deleted) on r/fragrance (December 14, 2022 – early review highlighting the subtle incense)
“Straight out the bottle, the fragrances top notes shine with a punchy sweet cinnamon and nutty smell… thick, dense, sweet vanilla… Arab fragrances have this feeling that gives you confidence and power.”
— Reddit user Paskow111 on r/fragrance (April 1, 2024)
“Mine is dated 01.2024… Its been nuclear from the start.”
— Reddit comment on performance in r/fragrance (June 19, 2024)
“Tldr; it lives up to the hype, one of the best fall/winter frags you can get…”
— Reddit user Upstairs_West6628 on r/fragranceclones (November 18, 2024)
Pros: Beast-mode longevity, compliment magnet, beautiful resinous drydown with myrrh/benzoin warmth, ties perfectly into holiday coziness.
Cons: Very sweet (can feel too gourmand if you hate dessert vibes), not super smoky/incense-forward compared to pure resin picks.
Current price: ≈ $35–$50 (100ml)
Khamrah took #2 because it nails that resinous amber luxury with addictive sweetness — perfect when you want smoky warmth but with a holiday twist. If you love my Angels’ Share content, this is your budget king.
#3: Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition – Glowing Sweet Amber Resin (Compliment Beast)
Let’s talk about the one that’s basically a **compliment machine** — Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition. This isn’t the deepest, smokiest **amber frankincense dupe** (no frankincense listed), but the amber here is front and center: glowing, warm, resinous, with a fruity-sweet twist that makes it feel ultra-luxe and addictive. It’s the popular affordable take on Xerjoff Erba Pura — juicy pineapple, melon, and candy-like fruits over a musky amber base.
The opening is bright and tropical — think fresh-cut pineapple and melon with a touch of citrus. Then the gourmand sweetness creeps in, blending with rich amber that gives it that resinous depth. The drydown? Smooth vanilla-musk with lingering woody amber that feels expensive and cozy. In cold weather, the amber really glows and adds that warm resin hug without heavy smoke.
My testing notes: I wore this on a few colder evenings — 3 sprays. Projection was strong for 4–6 hours (filled the room with fruity amber sweetness), then became a beautiful skin scent lasting 8–10 hours (longer on clothes). Got multiple compliments like “you smell amazing” or “what’s that expensive shampoo vibe?” It’s unisex but leans sweeter — perfect for holiday outings when you want to stand out positively.
Honest caveat: It’s very sweet and fruity — not a pure resinous incense like the top two. If you hate gourmand or anything shampoo-like, it might feel too much. But the amber resin base ties it nicely into this smoky/resinous theme, and the performance/price ratio is insane.
“This is by far my most complimented fragrance, it smells like an expensive shampoo and the projection and longevity is insane, it lasts 10+ hours on skin.”
— Reddit user on r/fragranceclones (May 24, 2024)
“A very fruity, sweet and fresh shampoo-like fragrance with top notch… I give it A10/10.”
— Reddit user Upstairs_West6628 on r/fragranceclones (December 31, 2024)
“Nuclear! Uplifting scent, lasts days on clothes. Current favorite in my collection.”
— Reddit post title on r/fragranceclones (March 15, 2024)
“Beautiful scent, just somewhat feminine and very very strong… made the mistake of wearing this to the office once.”
— Fragrantica review (March 2025 mention)
Pros: Massive compliments, strong longevity/projection, glowing amber resin warmth, feels niche for the price.
Cons: Very sweet/fruity (can feel feminine or overpowering), not smoky/incense-heavy.
Current price: ≈ $40–$50 (60ml–100ml variants)
It landed at #3 because the amber resin shine is gorgeous, but the heavy sweetness pushes it away from pure smoky frankincense territory. Still — if you want resinous luxury that gets noticed, this is a steal.
#4: Zimaya Ilham Al Oud – Smoky Oud-Frankincense Beast (Deep Resinous Power)
If you’re after a bold, smoky resinous kick with real oud depth, Zimaya Ilham Al Oud steps up hard. It’s commonly called an affordable take on Louis Vuitton Ombré Nomade (that $300+ raspberry-oud-rose beast), but with more emphasis on incense, leather, and smoky woods. No heavy raspberry here — instead, you get incense and agarwood upfront, blended with rose, saffron, and benzoin for that warm, balsamic resin glow.
The opening is smoky and leathery with a touch of rose — dark, mysterious, a bit animalic at times. The heart brings saffron spice and subtle fruity hints, while the base settles into deep oud, benzoin resins, and lingering smoke. It’s got that authentic Middle Eastern resinous intensity that ties perfectly into the amber & frankincense theme — think churchy incense meets woody amber warmth.
My testing notes: Wore this in cold weather — 3 sprays. Projection was solid for 3–4 hours (room-filling smoky aura), then became a strong skin scent lasting 8+ hours (eternal on fabric — one tester left it detectable for days). In chilly temps, the resins and smoke really expanded, feeling rich and confident. Side-by-side with other oud-resins, it held its own with impressive depth.
Be warned: It’s polarizing — the oud can feel animalic or “funky” to some, and the rose adds a floral edge that leans feminine for a few noses. Not a safe blind buy if you hate bold Arabic-style ouds. But if you crave smoky resinous power on a budget, this delivers big.
“Ilham Al Oud lasts on my skin for around 5-6 h (2-3h strong)… BUT on clothes lasts really long, lasted around 4 days while being still strong. Good cheap perfume, that smells like a rich guy.”
— Fragrantica user review (2024)
“This is a winner in my collection… devine smell if u like rose surrounded by oud and leather and none of them are overpowering each other.”
— Reddit user on r/fragranceclones (October 2023)
“Very safe choice, very polite and pleasing, practically no oud scent.”
— Reddit user cobaltcolander on r/fragranceclones (November 2024)
“The leather and oud is strong… I put it on my jumper over 48 hours ago and it still smells now!!”
— Reddit user on r/fragranceclones (April 2024)
Pros: Beast longevity on clothes, deep smoky resinous depth, feels authentic and luxurious for winter.
Cons: Can be animalic/funky, rose makes it lean feminine for some, not super fruity like the LV inspiration.
Current price: ≈ $25–$35 (100ml)
It ranked #4 because the smoky oud-resin power is fantastic, but the polarizing animalic edge and less frankincense purity hold it back from the top spots. Still — absolute steal for deep resin lovers.
#5: Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense – Deep Incense Smoke With a Spicy Amber Twist
This one is a heavy hitter in the clone world — Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense is widely regarded as one of the closest affordable takes on Creed Aventus with a smoky, incense-laden twist. But what lands it here? That deep amber-incense base that gives it serious resinous smoke, especially in the drydown. It’s not pure frankincense, but the combination of oakmoss, birch, and ambergris creates a dark, smoky resin glow that fits the theme beautifully.
The opening is classic Aventus-style: bright pineapple, bergamot, blackcurrant — fruity and smoky right away thanks to birch tar. Then spices roll in (cardamom, pink pepper), and the base settles into musky ambergris with heavy incense smoke and woody depth. In cold weather, the resinous smoke really takes over, making it feel moody and luxurious.
My testing experience: Wore this multiple times in chilly temps — 3–4 sprays. Projection was massive for 4–6 hours (that signature smoky pineapple cloud), then became a strong skin scent lasting 10+ hours (beast on clothes). Got compliments like “you smell rich” or “what’s that smoky vibe?” It’s versatile enough for evenings but bold enough for holiday impact.
Honest talk: The fruity top can feel out of place if you’re chasing pure churchy resins, and it’s more “smoky woody” than straight amber frankincense. Some batches vary in smokiness. But the resinous amber-incense depth in the base is undeniable, and performance is nuclear.
“The smoke is very prominent here… it’s a darker, smokier, more mature take on Aventus.”
— Reddit user on r/fragranceclones (August 12, 2024)
“Beast mode longevity and projection… the birch and incense really shine in the dry down.”
— Reddit user Powerful-Ship-7509 on r/fragranceclones (November 3, 2024)
“This is the smokiest Aventus clone I’ve tried… lasts forever on skin and clothes.”
— Fragrantica review (January 2025)
“Nuclear performer… the ambergris and smoke make it feel expensive.”
— Reddit comment on r/desifragheads (October 2024)
Pros: Insane longevity/projection, deep smoky resinous base, versatile winter wear, feels premium.
Cons: Fruity opening clashes for pure resin lovers, batch variations, more woody-smoky than frankincense-focused.
Current price: ≈ $40–$50 (100ml–150ml)
It took #5 because the smoky amber-incense depth is excellent, but the fruity Aventus DNA pulls it away from straight resinous purity. Still — if you want smoke with mass appeal, this crushes it.
#6: Rasasi La Yuqawam Pour Homme – Classic Resinous Amber-Leather Incense
Rounding out the list is a true classic in the affordable Middle Eastern fragrance world — Rasasi La Yuqawam Pour Homme. It’s famous as one of the best budget takes on Tom Ford Tuscan Leather (that $400+ raspberry-leather beast), but with more emphasis on suede, saffron, and resinous amber that gives it a warm, slightly smoky depth. No heavy frankincense here, but the amber-thyme combo creates a balsamic, resinous warmth that fits the holiday smoky vibe.
The opening hits with saffron spice and subtle raspberry fruitiness over smooth leather. The heart brings jasmine and woody notes, while the base settles into rich amber, suede, and resinous warmth with a touch of smoke. In cold weather, the amber resins really glow and add that cozy, luxurious layer — perfect for winter evenings.
My testing notes: Wore this to a couple of colder days — 3 sprays. Projection was strong for 4–5 hours (leathery amber cloud that felt sophisticated), then became a beautiful skin scent lasting 9–11 hours (monster on clothes). Compliments came in like “you smell classy” or “that’s expensive leather.” It’s masculine-leaning and mature.
Real talk: The raspberry can feel a bit synthetic or fruity-sweet at first, and it’s more leather-focused than pure smoky incense. Some find it too “Tuscan Leather clone” without enough originality. But the resinous amber base is solid and ties nicely into this roundup’s luxe winter feel.
“Very good clone of Tuscan Leather… the leather and amber are strong, longevity is beast mode.”
— Reddit user on r/fragranceclones (September 14, 2024)
“The amber and resins make it warm and cozy for winter… lasts all day easily.”
— Fragrantica review (November 2024)
“Classy and mature… the suede and amber drydown is addictive.”
— Reddit user cobaltcolander on r/desifragheads (March 2024)
“Nuclear performance… one of the best budget leather fragrances out there.”
— Reddit comment on r/fragranceclones (December 2024)
Pros: Excellent longevity/projection, classy resinous amber-leather warmth, mature winter vibe.
Cons: Raspberry opening can feel synthetic, more leather than pure smoky resin, very masculine.
Current price: ≈ $40–$50 (75ml)
It landed at #6 because the resinous amber warmth is great, but the leather-raspberry focus pulls it farther from straight amber frankincense smoke. Still — a solid, classy pick for anyone wanting luxe resin vibes with sophistication.
What If You Want Lighter Amber (Less Heavy Smoke)?
Not everyone wants to smell like they just walked out of a burning cathedral — fair enough. These smoky resinous picks are bold by design, but if heavy incense or beast-mode smoke feels too much for you (office, close quarters, or just personal taste), here are a few quick alternatives that still give you that warm amber glow without the intense smoke overload.
- Go sweeter/resinous: Stick with #2 (Lattafa Khamrah) or #3 (Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition). They lean gourmand and fruity-amber, so the resin warmth is there but wrapped in vanilla/cinnamon or pineapple candy — way more approachable and compliment-friendly.
- Try a lighter incense touch: If you like the idea of amber but want something softer, check out my Angels’ Share dupes roundup — many have subtle myrrh/benzoin resins with boozy warmth instead of straight smoke.
- Vanilla-amber comfort without smoke: Look into cozy holiday options from my Stronger With You Intensely dupes post — cinnamon-vanilla amber vibes that feel luxe but never churchy or smoky.
- Fresh resin twist: For a cleaner take, some bergamot-heavy picks in my bergamot guide pair citrus brightness with subtle amber bases — great if smoke isn’t your thing.
Bottom line: If pure smoky frankincense resins scare you off, start with Khamrah or Amber Oud Gold — you’ll still get that “insanely luxe” winter feel, just dialed back on the intensity. The top smoky beasts (#1, #4, #5) are for when you’re ready to go full resin mode.
Where to Buy These Right Now
Winter nights are perfect for smoky resinous scents, and these affordable amber & frankincense dupes are flying off shelves during holiday season — especially the top performers. Stock can dip low fast, but right now all six are in stock on Amazon with fast shipping options. Prices float a bit, but they’re all comfortably under $50.
Here are the direct links to the exact bottles I tested — click through for the latest price and availability. If you’re grabbing one for holiday gifts or your own winter rotation, don’t sleep on these.
#1: Afnan Supremacy Incense
The smokiest beast — pure incense luxury
≈ $35–$45 (100ml)
Check Price on Amazon#2: Lattafa Khamrah
Resinous warmth with sweet holiday coziness
≈ $35–$50 (100ml)
Check Price on Amazon#3: Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition
Glowing sweet amber — compliment magnet
≈ $40–$50 (60ml–100ml)
Check Price on AmazonPro tip: If something shows low stock, check the seller ratings and shipping times — Prime options usually deliver fastest. These are the bottles that will carry you through winter nights smelling insanely luxe without the guilt.
Final Thoughts + Which One I Reach For Most
After weeks of testing these six in real cold weather — holiday dinners, late-night drives, cozy evenings by the heater — I can say this without any hype: you don’t need to drop hundreds on niche resins to smell insanely luxe this winter. These affordable picks prove it. The gap between a $300+ smoky incense bottle and these under-$50 options isn’t as wide as the price tag suggests, especially in the first 6–10 hours when you’re actually around people.
That said, they’re not magic “exact clones.” Some lean sweeter, some go darker and animalic, others bring fruity or leathery twists. That’s okay — it gives you options depending on the mood. If you’re new to heavy resins, start lighter (Khamrah or Amber Oud Gold). If you’re already deep into Interlude or Ombré Nomade territory, go straight for the smoky beasts.
My personal ranking recap (and why):
- #1 Afnan Supremacy Incense — Hands down the smokiest, most intense amber frankincense dupe here. That churchy incense smoke hooked me hard. It’s bold, polarizing, and feels like pure luxury in the cold. My most-worn from the bunch.
- #2 Lattafa Khamrah — The cozy crowd-pleaser. Sweet resinous warmth that gets compliments everywhere. Perfect when you want luxe but approachable.
- #3 Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold — Compliment monster with glowing amber sweetness. Not smoky, but the resin depth shines.
- #4 Zimaya Ilham Al Oud — Deep, dark oud-resin smoke for days. Animalic edge keeps it lower, but incredible value.
- #5 Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense — Smoky incense with mass-appeal fruity top. Nuclear performer.
- #6 Rasasi La Yuqawam — Classy amber-leather warmth. Solid, mature, but least “frankincense-focused.”
Which one do I reach for most? Honestly, Afnan Supremacy Incense (#1). There’s something addictive about that raw, smoky frankincense punch — it makes me feel mysterious and put-together on cold nights. I sprayed it on my jacket a week ago and could still catch whiffs days later. Khamrah is a close second for when I want sweetness and compliments without the full smoke commitment.
If you’re on the fence: blind buy Supremacy Incense if you love heavy incense, or Khamrah if you want safer holiday coziness. Both are beasts for the price and will carry you through winter smelling way richer than you paid for.
At the end of the day, these proved to me that great smoky resinous scents don’t have to cost a fortune. I’ve spent stupid money on niche before — now I know better. Hope this helps you find your winter signature without the regret.
Let me know in the comments which one you’re grabbing (or if you’ve tried any already). Stay warm out there.
FAQ
If you’re new to smoky resinous scents, start with Lattafa Khamrah (#2) or Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition (#3). They’re warmer and sweeter, with resinous amber depth but without the intense churchy smoke that can overwhelm at first.
Afnan Supremacy Incense (#1) comes closest to that pure, smoky frankincense church vibe. Khamrah and the others use myrrh/benzoin for resinous warmth, but not straight frankincense. Supremacy Incense is the smokiest and most “incense-forward.”
Most lean masculine or unisex. Supremacy Incense, Zimaya Ilham Al Oud, and Supremacy Not Only Intense feel bold and masculine. Khamrah and Rasasi La Yuqawam are solidly unisex. Amber Oud Gold Edition leans sweeter and can read feminine to some.
Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense (#5) and Afnan Supremacy Incense (#1) are nuclear — easily 10+ hours on skin, days on clothes. Khamrah and Zimaya are close behind. All six are strong performers for the price.
Not really — these are bold winter beasts. Khamrah or Amber Oud Gold are the most “office-tolerant” because of the sweetness, but go light (1–2 sprays). The smoky ones (#1, #4, #5) can fill a room fast.
Al Haramain Amber Oud Gold Edition (#3) and Lattafa Khamrah (#2) are compliment magnets — sweet amber warmth draws people in. The smokier ones get “you smell mysterious” reactions more than outright compliments.
Yes, but carefully. Khamrah layers beautifully with vanilla or cinnamon scents. Supremacy Incense pairs well with light citrus to tone down the smoke. The heavier ones (#1, #4) stand strong alone.
Not at all in the drydown — the resinous bases feel rich and luxurious. Some openings (raspberry in La Yuqawam, pineapple in Not Only Intense) can feel a touch synthetic at first, but they smooth out fast.
Afnan Supremacy Incense (#1) — the smoky resins bloom in cold air and wrap you in that ancient, mysterious warmth. Khamrah is a close second for cozy holiday feels.
Khamrah and Amber Oud Gold are safest blind buys (crowd-pleasers). Avoid blind buying Supremacy Incense or Zimaya Ilham Al Oud if you’re sensitive to heavy smoke or animalic oud.
Related Posts
Angels’ Share Dupes: 6 Affordable Whiskey & Cinnamon Clones Under $45 for Winter Nights
Deep dive into boozy resinous warmth — Khamrah stars here too.
Khamrah vs Angels’ Share – Best Side-by-Side Blind Test
My brutal wrist-vs-wrist showdown — perfect if you’re eyeing #2.
Spicebomb Extreme Dupes: 7 Best Affordable Clones Under $45
More cozy winter spice and resin vibes — great follow-up for smoky lovers.
Best Stronger With You Intensely Dupes: 5 Cozy Cinnamon Vanilla Clones Under $40
Sweet resinous holiday warmth without heavy smoke — ties into the lighter alternatives.
9 Best Lattafa Perfumes That Smell Identical to Designer (With Dupes Chart)
Khamrah and other resinous Lattafa hits — deeper dive into the brand behind #2.
7 Best Gingerbread Perfume Dupes That Actually Smell Like Fresh-Baked Christmas Cookies (All Under $40)
Cozy holiday spice and sweetness — perfect companion to these resinous winter scents.